Court rules in favor of legal challenge against rule to end Duration of Status

On Monday, November 16, a federal district court ruled in favor of a legal challenge to the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS) rule to end Duration of Status (D/S) for exchange visitors, international students, and journalists. 

The court held that the rule was arbitrary and capricious, finding that DHS failed to adequately justify its approach or consider its potential impacts. The court's findings echoed concerns raised in the lawsuit, filed by a coalition led by NAFSA: Association of International Educators and the Presidents' Alliance for Higher Education, as well as in the Alliance's comment letter on the rule. Specifically, DHS failed to: 

  • appropriately weigh the rule's costs and benefits; 

  • justify the changes based on the fraud and national security concerns it stated; 

  • consider less burdensome alternatives; 

  • adequately respond to public comments; and   

  • meaningfully consider improvements to the existing Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS) as an alternative to imposing a costly new system. 

Furthermore, the ruling indicated that the restrictions on academic mobility were unreasonable and contrary to the intent of international student visas laid out in the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA).  

This decision preserves the D/S framework and prevents the rule’s fixed admission periods, extension-of-stay requirements, and restrictions on academic mobility from taking effect. DHS has the ability to appeal the court order within 60 days of the ruling, but there hasn’t been any confirmed reporting that they’ve done so or are planning to do so. 

Our sincere thanks go to Alliance for International Exchange member NAFSA and U.S. for Success partner the President’s Alliance for Higher Education for leading this successful legal challenge. We're also grateful to everyone in the Alliance and exchange community who submitted comment letters pushing back against the rule, shared data on the importance of D/S to BridgeUSA programs, and came together to share best practices. 

Previous
Previous

Senate appropriations subcommittee bill funds ECA at $667 million for FY27

Next
Next

Alliance Welcomes New Board of Directors Members